By Dr. Peter D. Maynard KC, PhD
5 min. read

The adversarial model used by most regulatory agencies is an inefficient, expensive, and conflict-producing procedure. Ill-adapted to resolving issues of great public policy concern, regulation calls out for non-adversarial alternative methods to address the resolution of policy disputes between the players in the regulatory arena. However, there must be a legislative framework and a culture of mediation. Furthermore, the parties must trust the neutral process of these non-adversarial methods.

The settlement of disputes by means of Alternative Dispute Resolution (‘ADR’) has several advantages. ADR:

(i) helps parties to save significant costs;

(ii) saves parties the delay from litigation in reaching finality in their disputes;

(iii) enables parties to achieve settlement of their disputes while preserving their existing commercial relationships and reputations;

(iv) provides parties with a wider range of solutions than litigation; and

(v) makes a substantial contribution to the more efficient use of judicial resources.

The Current Adversarial Model

The adversarial model of regulation mimics traditional courtroom procedures. It is designed to determine issues of fact, not issues of public policy. The development of the law is not conducive to the non-adversarial resolution of disputes. The fault lies in the absence of a legislative framework that  allows  a culture of ADR to develop. Regarding our justice systems, having a judge determine who is right or wrong, and who is the winner and the loser, is still very much a part of the general concept of justice. The notion of a win-win situation, and of building relationships, is still quite foreign to our traditional court systems.

Dispute Resolution: A Continuum

Dispute resolution refers to the range of options available to resolve disputes, from negotiation and consensus-building to litigation and adjudication. The options can best be viewed as a continuum: informal discussion and problem solving, negotiation, facilitation, fact-finding, neutral evaluation, mediation, conciliation, inquiry, board adjudication, arbitration, and the courts. This list is not exhaustive, and in some cases, more than one process may be used for different aspects of the same conflict to keep parties moving towards a complete solution.

At one end of the continuum are the means for resolution, which allow parties control over the process and the final arrangements; and at the other end is a procedure which results in a decision made for the parties. ADR refers to options other than going to court, or options that may be used together with litigation. The purpose is to help people explore and understand each other’s interests and develop acceptable solutions together.

Arbitration and Mediation defined

Arbitration is a process of adjudication in which evidence and arguments are presented to a neutral adjudicator or panel, empowered by the disputants to impose a binding decision or award.

Mediation is a voluntary process in which a neutral third party assists the parties in reaching their own settlement. The mediator does not have the power to impose a resolution; the role of the mediator is to help the parties achieve their own resolution.

Arbitration Under Bahamian Law

It should perhaps come as no surprise that the form of dispute resolution which has gained the greatest acceptance is the form which most closely mirrors the courts. Indeed, the word “arbitration” has 230 occurrences in the Laws of the Bahamas. Arbitration has an established statutory foundation in The Bahamas. The Arbitration Act (Ch. 180) provides the principal domestic legislative framework, while the Arbitration (Foreign Arbitral Awards) Act, 2009 addresses the recognition and enforcement framework for qualifying foreign arbitral awards. The Arbitration Act has also been subject to amendment, including the Arbitration (Amendment) Act, 2023 and the Arbitration (Amendment) Act, 2025. The scope and application of the legislation should therefore be considered by reference to the applicable amended provisions rather than solely by reference to the original Act.

Arbitration is particularly useful in commercial transactions where the parties wish to agree in advance upon a private mechanism for resolving future disputes. An appropriately drafted arbitration clause can identify the disputes covered, the method of appointing arbitrators, the seat of arbitration and other procedural matters. Parties should also consider the applicable arbitration rules and the legal requirements for recognition and enforcement of an award. The existence of an arbitration agreement does not eliminate every role for the courts. Court intervention may be relevant where the applicable legislation permits assistance with arbitral proceedings, challenges to an award or enforcement of an award. Arbitration has also been widely used by utility regulators through clear legislative provisions. It is useful to briefly discuss a few examples of such legislation.

Arbitration is established, in the Out Islands Utilities Act (Ch. 28), which encourages the construction of water supply and sewerage disposal systems on Out Islands by providing for the refund of customs duties and other concessions to the developer of such systems. Agreements under the Act are required to provide for the arbitration of all differences between the Minister and the developer. Under section 5 (4) (b) of the Out Islands Utilities Act (Ch. 28), every agreement shall contain mutual covenants on the part of the Minister and the licensed undertaker providing for the arbitration of all questions and differences between the Minister and licensed undertaker. The schedule to the South Eleuthera Water Supply Act (Ch. 198) contains a model agreement which provides that “in the event the Company fails to implement the requests of the Director of Public Works, or the Chief Medical Officer, this and all similar matters of dispute under this agreement shall be settled under The Arbitration Act”.

ADR Under the Supreme Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 2022

One of the most significant legal developments to ADR is the adoption of the Supreme Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 2022 (‘the new Rules’). The new Rules expressly recognize alternative dispute resolution as part of the civil litigation framework. Rule 2.1 defines an ADR procedure to include procedures for alternative dispute resolution, particularly mediation.

Rule 1.2 establishes the overriding objective of dealing with cases justly, including securing the just, most expeditious and least expensive determination of every cause or matter on its merits. More specifically, rule 25.1 addresses the Court’s duty actively to manage cases. The measures available include encouraging parties to settle all or part of their case on fair terms, promoting cooperation between parties and encouraging them to use an appropriate ADR procedure, particularly mediation, where the Court considers it appropriate.

Therefore, the current civil procedure framework expressly accommodates ADR as part of active case management.

The new Rules do not mean that every dispute must be mediated or that every party must accept a settlement. The appropriateness of ADR depends upon the circumstances of the case and the Court’s applicable powers. The practical significance is that parties and their attorneys should consider ADR at appropriate stages of litigation rather than treating it as an option only after substantial costs have been incurred.

Mediation/Conciliation

The mediation process is really not so new or foreign to us. Conciliation, defined by The United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, the core legal body of the United Nations (‘UNCITRAL’)as a process, whether referred to by the expression conciliation, mediation or an expression of similar import, whereby parties request a third person or persons (“the conciliator”) to assist them in their attempt to reach an amicable settlement of their dispute arising out of or relating to a contractual or other legal relationship, is synonymous with conciliation. The conciliator does not have the authority to impose upon the parties a solution to the dispute. Conciliation appears in the Bahamas laws 28 times, usually in a labour or multilateral investment setting. In the Industrial Relations Act (Ch. 321), Part VI, Trade Dispute Procedure, for example, the Minister may deal with trade dispute matters through conciliation through referring disputes to conciliation mechanisms.

While not expressed in the new Rules, conciliation mechanisms are available and gaining momentum in Bahamian Legislation, as evidenced through the Industrial Relations Act, which has had several amendments and additions, none of which have eliminated conciliation as a legal remedy. It should also be noted that the Department of Labour provides a free conciliation service for qualifying labour disputes. Its published guidance states that complaints should generally be brought within one year of the relevant matter.

Alternative Dispute Resolution in Other Caribbean Countries

Belize

In the Belize Supreme Court (Civil Procedure) Rules 2003, Part 25 deals with case management, and the court must further the overriding objective of dealing with cases justly, by actively managing cases. Under Rule 25.1 (c), the measures used by the court may include encouraging the parties to use any appropriate form of dispute resolution including, in particular, mediation (if the court considers that appropriate) and facilitating the use of such procedures.

Eastern Caribbean

In the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court Civil Procedure Rules 2000, from July 1, 2001 when the new Rules took effect, all new civil cases are subject to a reformed system contained in this new procedural code, including mediation.

Jamaica

In the Civil Procedure Rules 2002 of the Supreme Court, which came into effect on January 1, 2003, under Rule 25.1 (e), the court must further the overriding objective by actively managing cases, and this may include encouraging the parties to use any appropriate form of dispute resolution including, in particular, mediation, if the court considers it appropriate and facilitating the use of such procedures. Under Rule 25.4 (a), the person who conducts the conference may conduct a mediation, assisting the parties by meeting with them together or separately to encourage and facilitate discussion between them in an attempt to reach a mutually acceptable resolution of the dispute or any part of it.

Trinidad and Tobago

The Mediation Act 2004 (No. 8 of 2004) of Trinidad and Tobago, assented to on 27 February 2004, originally drafted by the Family Court Mediation Committee, creates and regulates a mediation profession. The Mediation Board is established, chaired by a Judge, to formulate standards for the accreditation of mediation training programmes and for the certification of mediators, mediation trainers and agencies, to accredit such programmes and to certify such mediators, mediation trainers and agencies. It provided for court annexed and also community mediations, and repealed the Community Mediation Act 1998 (No. 13 of 1998), which allowed mediation as an alternative to going to Court for certain summary offences and civil matters.

Future Legislative framework

Other prerequisites: Is that freedom of action encouraged? Are stakeholders involved? Are confidential and “without prejudice” conditions in place? Are mechanisms in place for reviewing the qualifications of mediators and assuring a high level of competence, determining the numbers of mediators on the roster and adding and removing mediators from the roster? Are there specific objectives and guidelines for performance and time lines for the mediation? Who will pay the costs? Are there effective methods for managing costs?

An Insider’s Perspective: Dr. Peter D. Maynard KC

As Founder and President of the International and Western Hemisphere Arbitration, Adjudication, and Mediation Centre (IWHAAM), I bring decades of experience in alternative dispute resolution, and have seen a myriad of circumstances and legal contexts.

For mediation to work, the stakeholders must understand the benefits and challenges of mediation. That is cured by better publicity. Also, the parties must trust the neutral process. As former President of the Bahamas Bar Association from 1997 to 2003, I have seen some very mixed results. Mediation was introduced as an almost free service provided through the Bahamas Bar in:

i. 1998, a 6 month pilot project on mediation regarding settling ancillary matters in divorces;

ii. 2001, restorative justice or mediation applied in the context of crime to bring compensation and healing to victims and a second chance for young offenders;

iii. 2004, as mediation is offered as a free service in the legal aid clinic of the Bahamas Bar Association.

But, the number of clients has been extremely low. The reasons commonly given were that the legislative framework was not present, that it was impossible to get the other party to agree to the mediation, and that one of the parties preferred to have a Judge decide the matter, with the finality and enforcement of the courts to back the decision.

How We Can Assist

Dr. Peter D. Maynard KC has 25 years of practice to act as arbitrator, has sat as sole arbitrator or on a panel of 3 arbitrators in labour matters and trust matters, and has done many formal and informal mediations. With a passion for access to justice for all and expertise in international human rights law, he is an advocate for legal aid and the development of human rights law and policy. 

For additional information regarding alternative dispute resolution or to schedule a consultation with Dr. Maynard, please contact Peter D. Maynard Counsel & Attorneys at 1-242-325-5335 or book one via our website.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and are provided for general informational purposes only. They do not necessarily reflect the views of Peter D. Maynard Counsel & Attorneys. This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Specific legal advice should be obtained in relation to individual circumstances.

Request Consultation